Crashes and bugs in Geometry Nodes: Boolean node #86498

New Issue

David · 2021-03-11T14:47:51+01:00

David commented

2021-03-11 14:47:51 +01:00

System Information
Operating system: Ubuntu 20.04
Graphics card: Geforce GTX 1080 + Geforce RTX 3070

Blender Version
Broken: Blender 2.93.0, Commit date: 2021-03-10 21:19, Hash 9ef24d5aaa
Worked: No version

The boolean node does not work as expected and also often crashes.

In 2.92 the "boolean node" does not work at all. For example if you make a cube and a sphere, and then setup a Point Distribution -> Point Instance using the cubes all over the sphere. Then try to do a boolean "difference" it does not work and only shows the original sphere (does not cut out the cubes). See Example:

In 2.93 the above example works as expected (See Example: ), however once added more complexity to your geometry blender becomes very slow, often crashes and boolean stops working after if you chain more than 1 boolean together.

Please see more complex example here:

In this case I'm creating some sprinkles and balls on top of a donut. Then I'm replicate the sprinkles and balls, scaling them up and joining them together. Then using the scaled sprinkles to cut out the original icing mesh and then joining it all back together. So that the sprinkles look like they have made indentations around them in the icing.

Here is my example blend file (with what I would think should be a working Geometry Nodes setup): donut.blend

Here is one of my crash logs:

# Blender 2.93.0, Commit date: 2021-03-10 21:19, Hash 9ef24d5aaa19
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=551, mouse_y=112, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.translate_attach(TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(74.6762, 41.3842, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":False, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={})  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=936, mouse_y=230, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.add_node(type="GeometryNodeJoinGeometry", use_transform=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.translate_attach_remove_on_cancel(TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(-143.356, 51.65, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":True, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={})  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=784, mouse_y=23, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.link(detach=False, has_link_picked=False, drag_start=(81.8958, -754.401))  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=1023, mouse_y=337, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.delete()  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=894, mouse_y=130, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=870, mouse_y=127, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.translate_attach(TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(220.851, 197.371, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":False, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={})  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=1065, mouse_y=235, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.link(detach=False, has_link_picked=False, drag_start=(665.043, -16.6589))  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=853, mouse_y=292, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.add_node(type="GeometryNodeBoolean", use_transform=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.translate_attach_remove_on_cancel(TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(-204.963, 152.803, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":True, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={})  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=888, mouse_y=322, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.link(detach=False, has_link_picked=False, drag_start=(383.816, 121.819))  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=190, mouse_y=208, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.link(detach=False, has_link_picked=False, drag_start=(-977.451, -59.0057))  # Operator
bpy.data.node_groups["Geometry Nodes"].nodes["Boolean"].operation = 'DIFFERENCE'  # Property
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=850, mouse_y=22, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.link(detach=False, has_link_picked=False, drag_start=(377.928, -530.844))  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=773, mouse_y=210, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.add_node(type="GeometryNodeAttributeFill", use_transform=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.translate_attach_remove_on_cancel(TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(-288.472, 30.2971, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":True, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={})  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=616, mouse_y=393, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.link(detach=False, has_link_picked=False, drag_start=(-216.975, -74.214))  # Operator
bpy.data.node_groups["Geometry Nodes"].nodes["Attribute Fill.001"].inputs[3].default_value = 0  # Property
bpy.data.node_groups["Geometry Nodes"].nodes["Attribute Fill.001"].inputs[1].default_value = "scale"  # Property
bpy.data.node_groups["Geometry Nodes"].nodes["Attribute Fill.001"].inputs[3].default_value = 1.1  # Property
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=905, mouse_y=263, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=600, mouse_y=331, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.duplicate_move(NODE_OT_duplicate={"keep_inputs":False}, TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(103.116, -207.86, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":False, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={}, NODE_OT_translate_attach={"TRANSFORM_OT_translate":{"value":(0, 0, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((0, 0, 0), (0, 0, 0), (0, 0, 0)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":False, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":1, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":False, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, "NODE_OT_attach":{}, "NODE_OT_insert_offset":{}})  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.duplicate_move(NODE_OT_duplicate={"keep_inputs":False}, TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(477.853, -166.288, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":False, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={}, NODE_OT_translate_attach={"TRANSFORM_OT_translate":{"value":(0, 0, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((0, 0, 0), (0, 0, 0), (0, 0, 0)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":False, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":1, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":False, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, "NODE_OT_attach":{}, "NODE_OT_insert_offset":{}})  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=983, mouse_y=199, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.translate_attach(TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(49.0428, -52.9098, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":False, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={})  # Operator
bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=565, mouse_y=132, extend=False, deselect_all=True)  # Operator

# backtrace
/home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender(BLI_system_backtrace+0x20) [0x9a18410]
/home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender() [0xf2182a]
/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/libc.so.6(+0x46210) [0x7f3a06df3210]
/home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender(sort_multi_input_socket_links+0x3d) [0x1c35bed]
/home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender() [0x1c36399]
/home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender() [0x12c672c]
/home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender() [0x12c7d47]
/home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender() [0x12c7eac]
/home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender(wm_event_do_handlers+0x416) [0x12c85d6]
/home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender(WM_main+0x20) [0x12befd0]
/home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender(main+0x31e) [0xe496ce]
/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/libc.so.6(__libc_start_main+0xf3) [0x7f3a06dd40b3]
/home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender() [0xf1e1ac]

# Python backtrace

**System Information** Operating system: Ubuntu 20.04 Graphics card: Geforce GTX 1080 + Geforce RTX 3070 **Blender Version** Broken: Blender 2.93.0, Commit date: 2021-03-10 21:19, Hash 9ef24d5aaa19 Worked: No version The boolean node does not work as expected and also often crashes. In 2.92 the "boolean node" does not work at all. For example if you make a cube and a sphere, and then setup a Point Distribution -> Point Instance using the cubes all over the sphere. Then try to do a boolean "difference" it does not work and only shows the original sphere (does not cut out the cubes). See Example: ![cubes_not_cutout](https://archive.blender.org/developer/F9885023/cubes_not_cutout) In 2.93 the above example works as expected (See Example: ![cubes_cut_working](https://archive.blender.org/developer/F9885040/cubes_cut_working)), however once added more complexity to your geometry blender becomes very slow, often crashes and boolean stops working after if you chain more than 1 boolean together. Please see more complex example here: ![Screenshot from 2021-03-11 13-45-22.png](https://archive.blender.org/developer/F9885034/Screenshot_from_2021-03-11_13-45-22.png) In this case I'm creating some sprinkles and balls on top of a donut. Then I'm replicate the sprinkles and balls, scaling them up and joining them together. Then using the scaled sprinkles to cut out the original icing mesh and then joining it all back together. So that the sprinkles look like they have made indentations around them in the icing. Here is my example blend file (with what I would think should be a working Geometry Nodes setup): [donut.blend](https://archive.blender.org/developer/F9885039/donut.blend) Here is one of my crash logs: ```lines=20 # Blender 2.93.0, Commit date: 2021-03-10 21:19, Hash 9ef24d5aaa19 bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=551, mouse_y=112, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.translate_attach(TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(74.6762, 41.3842, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":False, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={}) # Operator bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=936, mouse_y=230, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.add_node(type="GeometryNodeJoinGeometry", use_transform=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.translate_attach_remove_on_cancel(TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(-143.356, 51.65, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":True, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={}) # Operator bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=784, mouse_y=23, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.link(detach=False, has_link_picked=False, drag_start=(81.8958, -754.401)) # Operator bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=1023, mouse_y=337, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.delete() # Operator bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=894, mouse_y=130, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=870, mouse_y=127, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.translate_attach(TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(220.851, 197.371, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":False, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={}) # Operator bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=1065, mouse_y=235, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.link(detach=False, has_link_picked=False, drag_start=(665.043, -16.6589)) # Operator bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=853, mouse_y=292, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.add_node(type="GeometryNodeBoolean", use_transform=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.translate_attach_remove_on_cancel(TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(-204.963, 152.803, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":True, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={}) # Operator bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=888, mouse_y=322, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.link(detach=False, has_link_picked=False, drag_start=(383.816, 121.819)) # Operator bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=190, mouse_y=208, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.link(detach=False, has_link_picked=False, drag_start=(-977.451, -59.0057)) # Operator bpy.data.node_groups["Geometry Nodes"].nodes["Boolean"].operation = 'DIFFERENCE' # Property bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=850, mouse_y=22, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.link(detach=False, has_link_picked=False, drag_start=(377.928, -530.844)) # Operator bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=773, mouse_y=210, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.add_node(type="GeometryNodeAttributeFill", use_transform=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.translate_attach_remove_on_cancel(TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(-288.472, 30.2971, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":True, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={}) # Operator bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=616, mouse_y=393, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.link(detach=False, has_link_picked=False, drag_start=(-216.975, -74.214)) # Operator bpy.data.node_groups["Geometry Nodes"].nodes["Attribute Fill.001"].inputs[3].default_value = 0 # Property bpy.data.node_groups["Geometry Nodes"].nodes["Attribute Fill.001"].inputs[1].default_value = "scale" # Property bpy.data.node_groups["Geometry Nodes"].nodes["Attribute Fill.001"].inputs[3].default_value = 1.1 # Property bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=905, mouse_y=263, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=600, mouse_y=331, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.duplicate_move(NODE_OT_duplicate={"keep_inputs":False}, TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(103.116, -207.86, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":False, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={}, NODE_OT_translate_attach={"TRANSFORM_OT_translate":{"value":(0, 0, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((0, 0, 0), (0, 0, 0), (0, 0, 0)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":False, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":1, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":False, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, "NODE_OT_attach":{}, "NODE_OT_insert_offset":{}}) # Operator bpy.ops.node.duplicate_move(NODE_OT_duplicate={"keep_inputs":False}, TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(477.853, -166.288, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":False, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={}, NODE_OT_translate_attach={"TRANSFORM_OT_translate":{"value":(0, 0, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((0, 0, 0), (0, 0, 0), (0, 0, 0)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":False, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":1, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":False, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, "NODE_OT_attach":{}, "NODE_OT_insert_offset":{}}) # Operator bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=983, mouse_y=199, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator bpy.ops.node.translate_attach(TRANSFORM_OT_translate={"value":(49.0428, -52.9098, 0), "orient_type":'GLOBAL', "orient_matrix":((1, 0, 0), (0, 1, 0), (0, 0, 1)), "orient_matrix_type":'GLOBAL', "constraint_axis":(False, False, False), "mirror":True, "use_proportional_edit":False, "proportional_edit_falloff":'SMOOTH', "proportional_size":0.00271427, "use_proportional_connected":False, "use_proportional_projected":False, "snap":False, "snap_target":'CLOSEST', "snap_point":(0, 0, 0), "snap_align":False, "snap_normal":(0, 0, 0), "gpencil_strokes":False, "cursor_transform":False, "texture_space":False, "remove_on_cancel":False, "release_confirm":False, "use_accurate":False, "use_automerge_and_split":False}, NODE_OT_attach={}, NODE_OT_insert_offset={}) # Operator bpy.ops.node.select(wait_to_deselect_others=True, mouse_x=565, mouse_y=132, extend=False, deselect_all=True) # Operator # backtrace /home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender(BLI_system_backtrace+0x20) [0x9a18410] /home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender() [0xf2182a] /lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/libc.so.6(+0x46210) [0x7f3a06df3210] /home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender(sort_multi_input_socket_links+0x3d) [0x1c35bed] /home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender() [0x1c36399] /home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender() [0x12c672c] /home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender() [0x12c7d47] /home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender() [0x12c7eac] /home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender(wm_event_do_handlers+0x416) [0x12c85d6] /home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender(WM_main+0x20) [0x12befd0] /home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender(main+0x31e) [0xe496ce] /lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/libc.so.6(__libc_start_main+0xf3) [0x7f3a06dd40b3] /home/david/Applications/blender-2.93.0-9ef24d5aaa19-linux64/blender() [0xf1e1ac] # Python backtrace ```

David commented

2021-03-11 14:47:51 +01:00

Added subscriber: @dave140124802

Germano Cavalcante commented

2021-03-12 21:33:13 +01:00

Added subscriber: @mano-wii

Germano Cavalcante commented

2021-03-12 21:33:13 +01:00

Changed status from 'Needs Triage' to: 'Needs User Info'

Germano Cavalcante commented

2021-03-12 21:33:13 +01:00

Thanks for the report, but I'm not sure what are the steps to replicate the crash.
What should we do with the attached file?

Thanks for the report, but I'm not sure what are the steps to replicate the crash. What should we do with the attached file?

David commented

2021-03-13 11:28:55 +01:00

Sorry I can't seem to reproduce the crash reliably.

But you can see the boolean issue by opening up the donut.blend file and see that geometry nodes on the donut icing does not produce an expected result.

You'd expect the result to be a geometry where there is:

Icing
Indents in the ice from the scaled sprinkles
The sprinkles

Actual result:

Icing is totally missing
Only sprinkles showing

This appears to be a problem with the boolean not liking that some of the sprinkles intersect each other and that breaks the whole thing.

The performance is also really slow. It takes a few minutes for me to open the file and each setting change takes several minutes.

Sorry I can't seem to reproduce the crash reliably. But you can see the boolean issue by opening up the donut.blend file and see that geometry nodes on the donut icing does not produce an expected result. You'd expect the result to be a geometry where there is: - Icing - Indents in the ice from the scaled sprinkles - The sprinkles Actual result: - Icing is totally missing - Only sprinkles showing This appears to be a problem with the boolean not liking that some of the sprinkles intersect each other and that breaks the whole thing. The performance is also really slow. It takes a few minutes for me to open the file and each setting change takes several minutes.

Germano Cavalcante commented

2021-03-22 18:18:32 +01:00

Changed status from 'Needs User Info' to: 'Needs Triage'

Vladimir commented

2021-03-23 05:57:13 +01:00

Added subscriber: @Wovchick

Nicolas Lelong commented

2021-03-31 10:59:02 +02:00

Added subscriber: @rotoglup

Germano Cavalcante commented

2022-01-28 20:08:42 +01:00

Changed status from 'Needs Triage' to: 'Needs User Info'

Germano Cavalcante commented

2022-01-28 20:08:42 +01:00

I'm revisiting the reports, but I'm having a really hard time trying to understand this "complex" file.

As far as I could see, there is nothing unusual about the result.

Unfortunately the scenario described is too time consuming for us to track down, we require the bug reporter to narrow down the problem.

Normally .blend files can be simplified by removing most objects and disabling settings, until the problem reveals itself more clearly.

I'm revisiting the reports, but I'm having a really hard time trying to understand this "complex" file. As far as I could see, there is nothing unusual about the result. Unfortunately the scenario described is too time consuming for us to track down, we require the bug reporter to narrow down the problem. Normally .blend files can be simplified by removing most objects and disabling settings, until the problem reveals itself more clearly.

Germano Cavalcante commented

2022-02-07 22:28:42 +01:00

Changed status from 'Needs User Info' to: 'Archived'

Germano Cavalcante closed this issue

2022-02-07 22:28:42 +01:00

Germano Cavalcante commented

2022-02-07 22:28:42 +01:00

No activity for more than a week. As per the tracker policy we assume the issue is gone and can be closed.

Thanks for the report. If the problem persists please open a new report with the required information.

No activity for more than a week. As per the tracker policy we assume the issue is gone and can be closed. Thanks for the report. If the problem persists please open a new report with the required information.

Sign in to join this conversation.

No Label

Download

What's New

Blender Studio

Manual

Developers Blog

Documentation

Benchmark

Blender Conference

Development Fund

One-time Donations

Crashes and bugs in Geometry Nodes: Boolean node #86498