Triaging Migration Tasks #7

New Issue

Francesco Siddi · 2023-02-08T12:18:17+01:00

Francesco Siddi commented

2023-02-08 12:18:17 +01:00

Remaining

Update bug reporting youtube video (linked from issue templates)
metrics.blender.org update (dfelinto/blender-metrics)
High priority bugs listed in blender.chat script
source/tools/utils/weekly_report.py (moved to #52)
- API access to activity feed seems required for this
- Parsing RSS feed or public activity will not work, is incomplete (pagination missing)
Re-create Moderators team
- Just adding users add as needed instead
Update benchmark/studio/websites bug report links

Completed

Issue templates
- Blender
- Blender Add-ons
- Update template and redirect depending on final query having a prefix for fields or not
- Decide if branch reference should be set in issue template
Wrong empty reference when not specified in template
Avoid superfluous "Description" title added when using text area
Project filtering for issues
Redirect for Help > Report a Bug in Blender (Gitea side changes)
- URL to redirect to: http://projects.blender.org/blender/blender/issues/new?template=.gitea%2fissue_template%2fbug.yaml&body=...
Long template description is between title and text area
- Solved by reworking template layout so this is not as much of an issue
Good UI for inline images and file attachments
Ensure filters used by triagers work:
- Untriaged reports (phab query) - should just be filtering status/Needs Triage + type/Bug or type/Report if we keep it
- Reports waiting on info from users (phab query) - should just be filtering status/Needs Information from User
Where does BF Blender: Unconfirmed go?
- It's just 3 open tasks, marked them as Known Issue instead. These will be automatically tagged with project-slug:Bf Blender: Uncofirmed label, that could be renamed to something else after migration (perhaps type/Unconfirmed).
No enforcement that every bug has a status, type and priority label. Also no enforcement that status correctly corresponds to open/closed state. UI for applying labels does not enforce this. (scoped labels solve this)
Auto assign archived status when manually closing issue and not valid state closed was used. For auto closing with commit it's set to resolved (webhook)
Scoped labels should be at the top of the labels list (should be fixed by following new convention)
Verify API can query issues by date range (looks like it)
Single project / module assignment workflow is not ideal. More broadly we need a proper plan for how to handle cases where multiple modules are involved, and which labels to use.
Comment is lost when assigning a label or making other changes. (upstream bug)
Commits don't show issues referencing them, which is important for two reasons:
- Find duplicates of a bug
- Find follow up tasks and commits when backporting a commit

### Remaining - [ ] Update bug reporting youtube video (linked from issue templates) - [x] metrics.blender.org update (dfelinto/blender-metrics) - [x] High priority bugs listed in blender.chat script - [ ] `source/tools/utils/weekly_report.py` (moved to #52) - API access to activity feed seems required for this - Parsing RSS feed or public activity will not work, is incomplete (pagination missing) - [x] Re-create Moderators team - Just adding users add as needed instead - [x] Update benchmark/studio/websites bug report links ### Completed - [x] Issue templates - [x] Blender - [x] Blender Add-ons - [x] Update template and redirect depending on final query having a prefix for fields or not - [x] Decide if branch reference should be set in issue template - [x] Wrong empty reference when not specified in template - [x] Avoid superfluous "Description" title added when using text area - [x] Project filtering for issues - [x] Redirect for Help > Report a Bug in Blender (Gitea side changes) - URL to redirect to: http://projects.blender.org/blender/blender/issues/new?template=.gitea%2fissue_template%2fbug.yaml&body=... - [x] Long template description is between title and text area - Solved by reworking template layout so this is not as much of an issue - [x] Good UI for inline images and file attachments - [x] Ensure filters used by triagers work: - [x] Untriaged reports ([phab query](https://developer.blender.org/maniphest/project/2/query/PJwxd.0htZf_/)) - should just be filtering `status/Needs Triage` + `type/Bug` or `type/Report` if we keep it - [x] Reports waiting on info from users ([phab query](https://developer.blender.org/maniphest/project/2/query/cYYfff8kFIsW/)) - should just be filtering `status/Needs Information from User` - [x] Where does [BF Blender: Unconfirmed](https://developer.blender.org/project/view/50/) go? - It's just 3 open tasks, marked them as Known Issue instead. These will be automatically tagged with `project-slug:Bf Blender: Uncofirmed` label, that could be renamed to something else after migration (perhaps `type/Unconfirmed`). - [x] No enforcement that every bug has a status, type and priority label. Also no enforcement that status correctly corresponds to open/closed state. UI for applying labels does not enforce this. (scoped labels solve this) - [x] Auto assign archived status when manually closing issue and not valid state closed was used. For auto closing with commit it's set to resolved (webhook) - [x] Scoped labels should be at the top of the labels list (should be fixed by following new convention) - [x] Verify API can query issues by date range (looks like it) - [x] Single project / module assignment workflow is not ideal. More broadly we need a proper plan for how to handle cases where multiple modules are involved, and which labels to use. - [x] Comment is lost when assigning a label or making other changes. ([upstream bug](https://github.com/go-gitea/gitea/issues/22603)) - [x] Commits don't show issues referencing them, which is important for two reasons: - Find duplicates of a bug - Find follow up tasks and commits when backporting a commit

Brecht Van Lommel changed title from ~~Tasks and triaging UI~~ to Triaging Migration Tasks

2023-02-08 13:34:42 +01:00

Brecht Van Lommel commented

2023-02-08 13:35:32 +01:00

I moved the feature requests to #12, this one we can keep for a few remaining tasks do be done.

Brecht Van Lommel added the

Type

Feature

label 2023-02-08 16:59:52 +01:00

Brecht Van Lommel added the

Service

Gitea