@studio_punkt You mentioned that you used the exact same node setup in 3.6.
When you opened the file in 4.x did you change the Detail
value to 15.0
yourself or was it set to 15.0
automatically?
This is neither a performance regression nor unexpected behavior.
Let me explain: In 3.6 the Voronoi node didn't have a Detail
input, which is equivalent to setting the Detail
value to…
I'm guessing this gives a measure performance regression. It would be good to understand how big it is. Maybe we'll have to accept it.
@brecht I couldn't measure any performance differences: …
The noise is still continuous even after this change I think, though not differentiable. So maybe clarify the comment as well.
Since it's cutting a chunk of size 100000.0 out and pasting them…
Was the
isinf
there to fix this same issue?
Maybe, or maybe not. It was added by Brecht in 8cf374d401 (diff-c)
…
So it's highly likely the issue we're seeing in OSL is something precision related in the noise function that Cycles own noise implementation handles better.
Not really, both start to have…
I can confirm. The issue was introduced in 4.1 between
ca9c6372c94c
(Sep 28) and09caf5969010
(Nov 28)**System Information** Operating system: Windows-10-10.0.22621-SP0…
I intended it for main
branch, but having it in 4.1 doesn't hurt.