UI Experiment: Workspace Tooltip Previews #117008

Harley Acheson · 2024-01-11T01:41:59+01:00

Harley Acheson commented

2024-01-11 01:41:59 +01:00

Show previews of layouts in the tooltips of Workspace tabs.

More of a conversation starter than a useful thing.

The tooltips for all the Workspace tabs say the exact same thing: "Active workspace showing in the window." With this PR they instead show a graphical representation of the layout. This was something we've talked about a long time ago.

Show previews of layouts in the tooltips of Workspace tabs. --- More of a conversation starter than a useful thing. The tooltips for all the Workspace tabs say the exact same thing: "Active workspace showing in the window." With this PR they instead show a graphical representation of the layout. This was something we've talked about a long time ago. ![WorkspacePreviews.gif](/attachments/950ba98b-0669-40a4-9f91-ef610f98f136)

WorkspacePreviews.gif

56 KiB

👍 7 👀 2

Harley Acheson added 1 commit 2024-01-11 01:42:07 +01:00

fd139975e0 UI Experiment: Workspace Tooltip Previews

Show previews of layouts in the tooltips of Workspace tabs.

Harley Acheson added this to the User Interface project 2024-01-11 01:43:40 +01:00

Duarte Farrajota Ramos commented

2024-01-11 10:39:17 +01:00

First-time contributor

It would be interesting if we could somehow assign an editor icon for the workspace.
Say show a Compositor icon for the compositing workdpace, or an NLA or Curve editor for the Animation Workspace, etc.

The issue is I don't think there's a good way to determine one automatically, we need an UI to explicit assign one somehow.

Would an acceptable heuristic be to inferred an icon from the editor with the largest size by area? Would this be feasible within acceptable performance penalties?

It would be interesting if we could somehow assign an editor icon for the workspace. Say show a _Compositor_ icon for the compositing workdpace, or an _NLA_ or _Curve_ editor for the _Animation_ Workspace, etc. The issue is I don't think there's a good way to determine one automatically, we need an UI to explicit assign one somehow. Would an acceptable heuristic be to inferred an icon from the editor with the largest size by area? Would this be feasible within acceptable performance penalties?

Harley Acheson commented

2024-01-11 17:36:16 +01:00

It would be interesting if we could somehow assign an editor icon for the workspace.

That is worth experimenting with, but not sure it if that would give us anything more than the name itself.

Would an acceptable heuristic be to inferred an icon from the editor with the largest size by area?

That would need some thought. So many of the the layouts have the 3D View as the largest area. And even differentiating between modes might not be enough.

Would this be feasible within acceptable performance penalties?

We basically have a little blank bitmap - currently 128 pixels wide by a vertical amount that matches your current window - and we can draw anything on it we want. Currently just filling with the Editor Outline color and then filling a rectangle for each editor in its background color. This is pretty trivial.

If the little area is large enough we could show its icon at its top-left. Although I tend to think drawing something more representative in the middle would make more sense visually. As in the icon for a 3D object in the middle of 3DView, Icon representing an image in middle of Image editor.

Probably possible to get a bit fancier with the drawing of these areas but might be tricky to do so and not detract from the clear division lines between them.

> It would be interesting if we could somehow assign an editor icon for the workspace. That is worth experimenting with, but not sure it if that would give us anything more than the name itself. > Would an acceptable heuristic be to inferred an icon from the editor with the largest size by area? That would need some thought. So many of the the layouts have the 3D View as the largest area. And even differentiating between modes might not be enough. > Would this be feasible within acceptable performance penalties? We basically have a little blank bitmap - currently 128 pixels wide by a vertical amount that matches your current window - and we can draw anything on it we want. Currently just filling with the Editor Outline color and then filling a rectangle for each editor in its background color. This is pretty trivial. If the little area is large enough we could show its icon at its top-left. Although I tend to think drawing something more representative in the middle would make more sense visually. As in the icon for a 3D object in the middle of 3DView, Icon representing an image in middle of Image editor. Probably possible to get a bit fancier with the drawing of these areas but might be tricky to do so and not detract from the clear division lines between them.

Duarte Farrajota Ramos commented

2024-01-11 18:04:33 +01:00

First-time contributor

That is worth experimenting with, but not sure it if that would give us anything more than the name itself.
That would need some thought. So many of the the layouts have the 3D View as the largest area. And even differentiating between modes might not be enough.

Right, probably not a good idea by area size, not always enough to disambiguate meaningfully

If the little area is large enough we could show its icon at its top-left. Although I tend to think drawing something more representative in the middle would make more sense visually. As in the icon for a 3D object in the middle of 3DView, Icon representing an image in middle of Image editor.
Probably possible to get a bit fancier with the drawing of these areas but might be tricky to do so and not detract from the clear division lines between them.

I also pondered about drawing an icon for every area, but at this size it will probably just look confusing and cluttered.
Maybe drawing an icon or pictogram only for areas above a certain size solves the practical side of actually fitting the icon in the available space. Hopefully this would coincide vaguely with the purpose of a workspace assuming larger areas are more representative, though as you say it is a stretch, many will just be 3D views.

Drawing a Mode icon may give a little more hints about the goal, but at this point I'm wondering if it is worth sacrificing the current simplicity

> That is worth experimenting with, but not sure it if that would give us anything more than the name itself. > That would need some thought. So many of the the layouts have the 3D View as the largest area. And even differentiating between modes might not be enough. Right, probably not a good idea by area size, not always enough to disambiguate meaningfully > If the little area is large enough we could show its icon at its top-left. Although I tend to think drawing something more representative in the middle would make more sense visually. As in the icon for a 3D object in the middle of 3DView, Icon representing an image in middle of Image editor. > Probably possible to get a bit fancier with the drawing of these areas but might be tricky to do so and not detract from the clear division lines between them. I also pondered about drawing an icon for every area, but at this size it will probably just look confusing and cluttered. Maybe drawing an icon or pictogram only for areas above a certain size solves the practical side of actually fitting the icon in the available space. Hopefully this would coincide vaguely with the purpose of a workspace assuming larger areas are more representative, though as you say it is a stretch, many will just be 3D views. Drawing a _Mode_ icon may give a little more hints about the goal, but at this point I'm wondering if it is worth sacrificing the current simplicity

Harley Acheson commented

2024-01-11 21:35:02 +01:00

@DuarteRamos - Have you noticed a way of getting the bitmap of an interface icon?

Duarte Farrajota Ramos commented

2024-01-12 10:19:07 +01:00

First-time contributor

@DuarteRamos - Have you noticed a way of getting the bitmap of an interface icon?

I only know how to get icon to show in Python layouts, but I don't think it would be useful here, would it?

> @DuarteRamos - Have you noticed a way of getting the bitmap of an interface icon? I only know how to get icon to show in Python layouts, but I don't think it would be useful here, would it?

Brecht Van Lommel commented

2024-01-12 14:17:54 +01:00

Personally I don't think this is solving any real problem, there is no need to preview an action like this when you can just do it. The particular layout is also not the important information, it's the editors and modes that are used.

I would not add this type of functionality.

Personally I don't think this is solving any real problem, there is no need to preview an action like this when you can just do it. The particular layout is also not the important information, it's the editors and modes that are used. I would not add this type of functionality.

Harley Acheson commented

2024-01-12 17:30:30 +01:00

@brecht - ...don't think this is solving any real problem...I would not add this type of functionality.

Yeah, was hoping that it could turn into something useful, but definitely not as is here.

Current best thought is to include the icons of the editors, but it looks to be a pain to get the bitmaps of these:

Surprisingly, this type of thing is quite readable, but would require us supplying an image (just on disk) for each workspace:

> @brecht - ...don't think this is solving any real problem...I would not add this type of functionality. Yeah, was hoping that it could turn into something useful, but definitely not as is here. Current best thought is to include the icons of the editors, but it looks to be a pain to get the bitmaps of these: ![image](/attachments/2225676b-f749-4163-a1c0-5324b0d14fae) Surprisingly, this type of thing is quite readable, but would require us supplying an image (just on disk) for each workspace: ![image](/attachments/faf6983c-8f24-4479-a8aa-601ebec2cc96)

image.png

54 KiB

image.png

39 KiB

👍 2

ryan-bailey commented

2024-01-12 23:02:29 +01:00

First-time contributor

Seems like an exercise in finding things to do versus actually improving what is improperly implemented or unfinished.

Harley Acheson commented

2024-01-12 23:15:02 +01:00

Seems like an exercise in finding things to do versus actually improving what is improperly implemented or unfinished.

Was playing around with this on the weekend. In my spare time I will work on anything I like, just as you do.

> Seems like an exercise in finding things to do versus actually improving what is improperly implemented or unfinished. Was playing around with this on the weekend. In my spare time I will work on anything I like, just as you do.

ryan-bailey commented

2024-01-12 23:46:59 +01:00

First-time contributor

Was playing around with this on the weekend. In my spare time I will work on anything I like, just as you do.

Maybe my post had an improper tone. I simply meant for Blender’s greater ultimate focus, since this is the site for Blender’s development. If you don’t want feedback, just let me know.

> Was playing around with this on the weekend. In my spare time I will work on anything I like, just as you do. Maybe my post had an improper tone. I simply meant for Blender’s greater ultimate focus, since this is the site for Blender’s development. If you don’t want feedback, just let me know.

Harley Acheson closed this pull request

2024-01-21 19:29:38 +01:00

Pull request closed

Please reopen this pull request to perform a merge.

Sign in to join this conversation.

No reviewers

No Label

Download

What's New

Blender Studio

Manual

Developers Blog

Documentation

Benchmark

Blender Conference

Development Fund

One-time Donations

UI Experiment: Workspace Tooltip Previews #117008

Pull request closed